‘Israel: The Scourge of Empires – World War I.’
ישראל: מכת האימפריות – מלחמת העולם הראשונה
Israel’s role in World War I was significant, impacting empires and causing geopolitical shifts
EPISODE EIGHT: ‘Israel: The Scourge of Empires – World War I.’
SYNOPSIS
This podcast episode exposes Israel’s significant role in World War I, linking its influence to the decline of Western empires. It critiques Zionism as a harmful ideology and advocates for equality among religions in Palestine. Said episode also explores historical shifts in empire dynamics and emphasizes peaceful resolutions to global conflicts.
ATTENTION: This podcast is being heavily censored / shadow banned WORLDWIDE. TO AVOID ANY LISTENING ISSUES PLEASE DOWNLOAD SAID EPISODE.
Podcast Host
Podcast Narrator
Gray M. Stanton
Gray is unique among podcast hosts. His decades-long historical research enriches his interviews. Analyzing forensic evidence also adds depth to his podcasts to date.
Bryan Lee Jr.
Bryan is an internationally acclaimed podcast narrator across hundreds of book publications on Audible. Which is why his skill and dedication were sought as he compliments Gray’s overall analyses.
The Destroyers Of The World
“We Jews, we, the destroyers, will remain the destroyers forever.” – Maurice Samuel
“אנחנו היהודים, אנחנו, המחריבים, נישאר המשמידים לנצח”.
Empires historically collapse due to foreign entanglements and alliances, often leading to unsustainable expansions and wars. Notably, many Western empires have faced downfall linked to their involvement with Israel, a trend that warrants recognition to prevent future crises.
אימפריות קורסות היסטורית עקב הסתבכויות ובריתות זרות, מה שמוביל לעתים קרובות להתרחבות ומלחמות שאינן בנות קיימא. יש לציין כי אימפריות מערביות רבות עמדו בפני נפילה הקשורה למעורבותן בישראל, מגמה המצדיקה הכרה כדי למנוע משברים עתידיים.
“Blessed are the peacemakers: for they shall be called the children of God.”
KJV: Matthew 5:9
References:
_________________________________________________
Ancient Map of Palestine 1020 BC
SUMMARY
Israel’s Role in World War I: Israel played a significant role in World War I, impacting various empires with its strategic position and actions.
Critique of Zionism: SAID episode critiques Zionism as a harmful ideology and advocates for equality among religions in Palestine.
Historical Shifts in Empire Dynamics: ThIS episode explores historical shifts in empire dynamics and emphasizes peaceful resolutions to global conflicts.
Influence of the Rothschild Family: The Rothschild family had a profound impact on global finance, the establishment of Israel, and the control of money creation in the United States.
Palestinians still suffer after 100 years of Balfour Declaration
Palestinians especially refugees continue to reel under Balfour declaration.
British and German Empires: Both Great Britain and German empires supported the recreation of Old Testament Israel, leading to World War II and their eventual decline as major powers.
Prof. Dr. Hans Freudenthal (1905 – 1990) discussed the collaboration between Zionism and the Third Reich in the 1930s. Both groups agreed that Jews were a distinct nationality that did not belong in Germany, leading Zionists to advocate for Jewish resettlement in Palestine. The Nazi regime supported this idea, facilitating Jewish emigration through the Haavara (Transfer) Agreement, which allowed German Jews to move to Palestine with their wealth. Despite some opposition, Hitler supported the agreement, recognizing its benefits. However, German support was limited to a Jewish homeland under British control, not an independent Jewish state. This collaboration, despite its contradictions, ultimately influenced the foundation of the State of Israel.
The collaboration between Zionism and the Third Reich was marked by several contradictions:
- Ideological Paradox: Despite the Nazi regime’s anti-Semitic stance, they supported Zionism and Jewish emigration to Palestine. This collaboration was symbolized by a Zionist-owned ship displaying both Hebrew letters and a swastika.
- Shared Goals with Divergent Motivations: Both groups agreed that Jews were a distinct nationality that did not belong in Germany, leading Zionists to advocate for Jewish resettlement in Palestine. However, while Zionists aimed to establish a Jewish homeland, the Nazis sought to reduce the Jewish population in Germany.
- Support for Jewish Nationalism: The Nazi regime promoted Jewish schools and cultural organizations to foster a sense of Jewish nationalism, which aligned with Zionist goals. Yet, this support was limited to a Jewish homeland under British control, not an independent Jewish state.
- Economic and Political Reservations: The Haavara (Transfer) Agreement facilitated Jewish emigration to Palestine while transferring their wealth. Despite its benefits, some German officials opposed the arrangement due to its economic drawbacks and potential to strengthen anti-German sentiments worldwide.
- Shift in Official Policy: Initially, the German government supported Zionist ambitions, but later expressed greater sympathy for Palestinian Arab resistance to Zionist goals, reflecting a shift in official policy.
These contradictions illustrate the complex and often paradoxical nature of the collaboration between Zionism and the Third Reich under Adolf Hitler in WWII.
Talking about terrorism
Irgun Blows Up British HQ at Jerusalem’s King David Hotel 79 years ago.
On July 22, 1946, the Irgun pre-state Jewish underground paramilitary movement bombed the King David Hotel in Jerusalem, killing 91 and wounding 46. The attack destroyed the centre of the British Mandatory administration and led to a split within the Jewish community in the Land of Israel.
The Nazi idea of “Judah” is identical to the anti-Zionist conception of “Israel”.
The Jewish Employee in this article was sent to Dachau. The below study examines the scarce and contradictory evidence surrounding the alleged gas chamber at Dachau Camp, highlighting the impracticality of the equipment for extermination and the presence of real showerheads, while acknowledging the injustice of imprisonment and mistreatment during World War II.
_________________________________________________
The murder of tens of millions of Aryans by Ashkenazim Khazarian Jewish Bolsheviks – the REAL Holocaust.
Jewish Post, May 25, 1934, 2, Hoosier State Chronicles.
AP reported on the Egyptian and other Arab states’ reaction to Israeli independence in 1948: “The weekly Akhbar el Yom said 600 persons, mostly Zionists, were rounded up and sent to concentration camps.”
Conflicting British Government interpretations of the Hussein McMahon correspondence of 1915, showing interpretations from 1918 and 1922.
UK Government – UK Government. Foreign Office memorandum published at least as early as Arab Observer, Issues 202-219, General Organization of Publications, 1964, page: clxv White Paper published June 1922.
Description: “Memorandum to the Protestant Powers of the North of Europe and America”, Colonial Times (Hobart, Tasmania, Australia), 23 February 1841, page 1, column 3. Reprinted from The Times (London), 26 August 1840, pp. 5-6.
German Jews to Palestine, & Australia.
UNITED STATES Connection to Israel: The UNITED STATES deep connection to Old Testament Israel has led to numerous conflicts, economic strain, and moral decline.
Description
Contributions from various authors: Edited by Harry Elmer Barnes, this collection features historical revisionist essays by Dr. Charles Callan Tansill, Dr. Frederic R. Sanborn, Dr. William L. Neumann, George Morgenstern, Percy L. Greaves, Jr., William Henry Chamberlin, and Dr. George A. Lundberg. These essays explore the duplicity of American foreign policy leading up to the Second World War, offering a transformative perspective on how America was drawn into the conflict.
_________________________________________________
The Primary Cause of 2023 October 7 Was Donald Trump. Here’s the Proof
Synopsis: This Episode critically analyses the geopolitical consequences of the Abraham Accords, emphasizing their role in sidelining Palestinian interests and exacerbating tensions in the region. It highlights how these agreements have led to increased desperation among groups like Hamas, viewing normalization with Israel as a threat to Palestinian identity and rights.
Impact on Palestinian Identity: The Abraham Accords are argued to undermine Palestinian statehood aspirations, contributing to a perception of betrayal among Palestinians and escalating conflict. This dynamic is linked to the 2023 October 7 attacks by Hamas, which were seen as a calculated response to regain international attention on Palestinian issues.
Authoritarian Conflict Management: The accords are characterized as a mechanism for authoritarian conflict management, reinforcing domestic repression in Arab states while failing to address the root causes of the Israeli Palestinian conflict. This has resulted in a cycle of violence and repression, complicating the path to genuine peace.
“Authoritarian conflict management”??
QUESTION: What does that mean?
ANSWER: It means that the inducements for participation in the Abraham Accords had more to do with strengthening domestic repression than promoting regional peace.
For example, Arab Israeli normalization has led to increased investment in Israeli defence and cybersecurity industries by Arab regimes, which use these technologies to suppress dissent. This dynamic has directly impacted journalists, activists, and intellectuals, who are often targeted and imprisoned. While Israel is not the only source of repressive technologies, normalization has diversified and strengthened the capacities of Arab governments.
The Abraham Accords aim to reinforce the US and Israel’s regional agenda by supporting existing dictatorships, rather than advancing peace in the Middle East. This normalization perpetuates the 78-year occupation and ongoing violence against Palestinians.
U.S. President Trump’s foreign policy, initially presented as “America First,” has significantly favoured Israel. His actions, such as recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and suppressing anti-Israel protests in the United States, have prioritized Israel’s interests. These policies have destabilized the Middle East, undermined diplomatic efforts concerning the Israel-Palestine conflict, and laid the groundwork for criminalizing criticism of Israel in the United States. While his attempts to address the Russo-Ukrainian conflict are commendable, his blind spot regarding Israel raises questions about the balance of power between Washington and Tel Aviv.
Jews reject Christ as a “failed Messiah” and believe the real Messiah (i.e. the Antichrist) will be a “great warrior” who will vanquish Jewish enemies and bring about Jewish world hegemony a.k.a. “peace.” Is this Donald Trump?
_________________________________________________
As stated by Henry Makow, the alt media is false opposition. Henry asked Mike Adams, Greg Hunter, and Candice Owen to interview him – never mind Tucker Carlson, Stew Peters or Joe Rogan. Henry was also quoted saying, “No one wants the ugly truth. Trump, Putin & Netanyahu belong to Chabad, a Jewish supremacist cult that plans to genocide “non-Jews” again under the guise of another world war. Freemasons have orchestrated every world war to undermine Western civilization and kill patriots. The leaders of Iran, Hamas, Hezbollah, Israel, the US & EU and China are Freemasons planning this world war.”
Patrick O’Carroll summarizes a recent interview Henry Makow did with Kevin Barrett.
Starting at about 12 minutes, Dr. Kevin Barrett interviews the great Henry Makow, who is a notable anti-Zionist Jew and an ardent critic of the Gnostic-Dualist (Luciferian) doomsday sect CHABAD, whose members “coincidentally” include Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, Benjamin Netanyahu, Volodymyr ZioLensky, Javier Milei …
Henry Makow opens with the following statement regarding the “Illuminati” Jews, who are essentially CHABAD Satanists: “My take is that Judaism has been taken over by a cult called the CHABAD, who are Kabbalists and Satanists. And, unfortunately, most of the central-banksters belong to them. Even worse, the Kabbalists believe that the world was created FOR Jews and that the Goyim ‘Livestock’ must worship Jews as ‘god’ or else be exterminated. I know that this is ridiculous and that it is not the view of the vast majority of Jews, who are ignorant of this. But, nonetheless, it is what has happened. Judaism, and hence banking, and hence the whole world, has been subverted by this satanic cult called the CHABAD. That is my extreme finding that no one wants to acknowledge and I do not blame them, since it is pretty frightening. AND I HOPE I AM WRONG”.
The best evidence that Trump is a CHABAD-member is that he made a special effort to visit the grave of the main CHABAD Antichrist-like figure Menachem Mendel Schneerson on 7 Oct 2024, the anniversary of the attacks by the Antichrist State of Israel (which ZioFascist “defense” minister Yoav Gallant admitted the ZioFascists went along with as a false-flag to “justify” the launch of the Gaza Holocaust).
By now, about 1 million Arabic-Semites have been genocided in the Gaza Holocaust since 7 Oct 2023. That increased the overall death-toll of the Arabic-Semitic Holocaust to 12 million since 1948. What bigger signal of ZioFascist Trump being a CHABAD-member could you wish for than that visit? That is about as clear, or as demonstrative, a signal as you are going to get.
Note: Although many considered Schneerson to be the Antichrist, he himself eschewed this praise in 1994, when he made a highly revealing statement to his followers. He told them that the Antichrist will not arrive until the Jews have first done their “sacred” duty by genociding MOST Christians so as to “merit” the arrival of the Antichrist, who will ultimately reward them by granting them the Talmudic “new” world order and by granting every Jew 2800 Goyim “Livestock” (“animals”) as his slaves in perpetuity. Among these slaves will be the Christian minority who survive the massive cull. The slaves are confirmed by Talmud Simeon Haddarsen, fol. 56-D, which states: “When the Jewish messiah [i.e. the Antichrist] comes, every Jew will have 2800 slaves”.
What Henry is saying is that US Christians, and especially “Christian” Zionists, simply do not want to even acknowledge that Trump idolizes the main CHABAD Antichrist-like figure Schneerson, who openly stated that all Christians must be genocided as the very PREREQUISITE for the Talmudic “new” world order to arrive.
Henry adds: “With the help of their Gentile Freemason lackeys, the ‘Illuminati’ Jews and the CHABAD Satanists have been sabotaging Western civilization for 300-400 years now. And I have tons of evidence in my four ‘Illuminati’ books that they are on both sides of every war, because that is the way they undermine Western civilization and increase their power and money”.
Kevin is skeptical about Putin being a member of CHABAD, and cites the 2011 book “Everyday Saints and Other Stories” by Russian author (now metropolitan) Archimandrite Tikhon, who is Putin’s Orthodox spiritual advisor.
But Henry counters: “There are hundreds of pictures of Putin with CHABAD rabbi Berel Lazar, who also stated that, as a child, the CHABAD practically adopted Putin. In the 1990s. Schneerson stated the CHABAD planned to start a war between Russia and Ukraine as the only way to exterminate more of what he called ‘obstinate’ Slavs”.
Kevin acknowledges the Big Picture: Freemasonry was taken over by Sabbatean-Frankism which was led first by Sabbatai Zevi in 1650-75 (who proclaimed himself the Antichrist or Jewish “messiah” in 1666) and later led by Jacob Frank in 1740-90 (who proclaimed himself the Antichrist AND the reincarnation of the previous Antichrist Sabbatai Zevi).
Around 1800, the Zionist House of Rothschild took over Sabbatean-Frankism, essentially making it what is today dubbed “the satanic Rothschild synagogue of Sabbatean-Frankism”. This synagogue has a diabolical plan to destroy everything and then to rebuild and rule, and this is essentially the ideology of both Sabbatean-Frankist Freemasonry and the Sabbatean-Frankist CHABAD.
Henry adds: “That is EXACTLY the agenda that is running the world, except that they are on both sides of every conflict. One side is the Zionist side in London, NYC, Tel Aviv, and their supporters in Ukraine, Argentina etc. On the other side is the Bolshevik side [partly led by George Soros and his son Alex Soros] which is mainly Russia, China, and Iran. But Sabbatean-Frankist Freemasonry and the Sabbatean-Frankist CHABAD run both sides, with the stated goal of pitting these two sides against each other in WW3, in order to depopulate the world”.
Henry adds: “We must fight the enemy because the enemy cannot herd cats. And, if we merely connect the dots, the picture that emerges is horrifying. But, if we want to fight the enemy, we should at least know who he is”.
Kevin mentions how lib-tard Jewish professor Sandra Lubarsky totally shocked him when she claimed (actually fully in line with the satanic Talmud): “Today, we Jews are all in agreement that ‘god’ means the Jewish people”.
Henry concurs, adding that, in the eyes of Satanist Jews, the biggest “mistake” that the Goyim “Livestock” are making today is that they are not worshipping Organized Jewry as “god”.
Henry adds an apt quote that British-Freemasonic-Agent “Voltaire” (François-Marie Arouet) gave already as early as 1771: “The Jews are born with a raging fanaticism in their hearts, just as the Germans are born with blond hair. I would not in the least be surprised if these people would some day become deadly to the human race”.
Henry: “Assimilated Jews are really the ‘opposite’ of Zionist Jews [because they serve their nation rather than the Antichrist State of Israel]. But, Assimilated Jews are being set up to take the blame for a coming calamity. And Assimilated Jews have got to STAND UP, like I am doing. Apart from that, the CHABAD fully intends to kill Assimilated Jews who do not believe that Organized Jewry is ‘god’ …”.
Henry adds: “Always keep in mind that the Sabbatean-Frankist Jews, also called the Kabbalist Jews, also called the CHABAD Satanists, absolutely WORSHIP death and destruction, expecially whenever those happen to the Goyim ‘Livestock’. And when I say Kabbalist Jews, I do not mean ordinary or Assimilated Jews, who are dupes like everyone else. Remember that the AGENDA OF THE CHABAD IS DESTRUCTION”.
“Marching to Zion,” a documentary by Baptist Pastor Steven Anderson, challenges the belief that Jews are “God’s Chosen People,” emphasizing God’s universal love.
Both Christians and Jews are recognizing that Cabalist Judaism, which deifies Cabalist Jews, is a satanic cult.
The Scofield Bible, financed by Zionist bankers, deceived Christians. Christian Zionist pastors and pro-Zionist politicians are considered traitors.
Christians will realize that the Dept. of Homeland Security and NSA protect the Federal Reserve Bank and Zionist political establishment, with terrorism being a pretext by the CIA and FBI.
_________________________________________________
Modern-day Israel’s Influence: Modern-day Israel’s policies and actions have had a detrimental impact on the empires that allied with it. GIVEN CURRENT EVENTS IT WOULD APPEAR THE SEED OF ONE’S DESTRUCTION OFTEN COMES FROM WITHIN.
Rebellion within the army and Mossad: Israel faces unprecedented internal mutiny
9,500+ civilians, including academics, teachers, and doctors, signed petitions to end the war for hostage release.
Israeli forces killed nine paramedics, five civil defense workers, and a UN employee on 23 March 2025, according to Gaza officials
On 27 and 30 March 2025, officials found 15 ambulance and firefighting crew members buried 200 meters from their vehicles.
Zionism Critique: Zionism is exposed as a belief that modern Jews have the right to establish Israel in Palestine, despite not being descendants of the original Judahite Hebrews.
Description
“Pontius Pilate inscribed ‘Jesus Nazarenus Rex Iudeorum’ on the cross, meaning ‘Jesus the Nazarene Ruler of the Judeans.’ The term ‘Jew’ did not appear in English until the 18th century. Jesus referred to himself as a Judean, while modern-day Jews were historically Khazars, a Mongolian Nordic tribe.”
Title: Facts Are Facts, Benjamin Freedman, ISBN:9780979917660, publisher: Bridger House Publishers, 2009.
_________________________________________________
Key Points from “The Etymology of the Word ‘Jew’”
Historical Evolution: The word “Jew” originated from the Latin “Iudaeus” found in St. Jerome’s Vulgate Edition and evolved through various English forms over the centuries, including “Gyu,” “Giu,” “Iu,” “Iuw,” “Iewe,” and finally “Jew” in the 18th century.
Introduction into English Translations: The word “Jew” was first introduced into English translations of the New Testament in the 18th century. Prior to this, the word did not appear in earlier translations such as the Rheims (Douai) Edition and the King James Authorized Edition.
Pronunciation Changes: The pronunciation of the word “Jew” has changed over time. In modern English, the “J” in “Jew” is pronounced like the “J” in “justice,” “jolly,” and “jump,” which is a development of recent times. Prior to the 18th century, the “J” in “Jew” was pronounced like the “Y” in “yes,” “youth,” and “yacht”.
Secondary Meaning: During the 18th, 19th, and 20th centuries, a well-organized and well-financed international “pressure group” created a so-called “secondary meaning” for the word “Jew” among English-speaking peoples. This secondary meaning bears no relation to the original connotation of the word “Jew”.
Biblical Context: In the current Bible (New Testament), the word “Jew” means a resident of the land of Judaea regardless of their tribe, race, or religion. The document emphasizes that the modern understanding of the word “Jew” is different from its biblical meaning.
_________________________________________________
History of the so called Jew.pdf
_________________________________________________
Author Details: Department of Hematology, Hebrew University, Hadassah Medical School; Laboratory of Biological Anthropology and Ancient DNA, Hebrew University, Hadassah School of Dental Medicine, Jerusalem, Israel; Institut für Rechtsmedizin, Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität, Münster, Germany.
Author Details: Department of Animal and Plant Sciences, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK, Manipal Centre for Natural Sciences (MCNS), Manipal University, Manipal, Karnataka, India, Department of Linguistics, Tel Aviv University, Tel-Aviv, Israel, Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Johns Hopkins University.
Author details: Department of Haematology and Genetic Pathology, School of Medicine, Flinders University, Adelaide, Australia. Department of Human Genetics, Sackler Faculty of Medicine, Tel-Aviv University, Israel. Current Address: Blood Bank, Sheba Medical Center, Ramat-Gan 52621, Israel.
NOTE: Refer to references #53, and #54 as stated in below quote in the above posted peer-reviewed-medical-journal page 16.
“As written in the Discussion the genetic distance
Avshalom Zoossmann-Diskin
matrices of Atzmon et al. [53] and Behar et al. [54] do
not contradict my results, but reinforce them.”
Israel has directly targeted more than 400 schools in Gaza since October 7
88% of Gaza’s schools are damaged in the attacks.
Jewish Question: The historical and contemporary significance of the “Jewish Question” is investigated, tracing the increasing power and wealth of impostors claiming to be Judahite Hebrews.
Description
This book discusses the historical context of the “Jewish Question,” tracing its origins back to ancient Rome and detailing how Jewish communities gained wealth and power throughout the Christian era. It highlights the negative perceptions of Jews expressed by various historical figures and the compilation of 16 classic essays aimed at providing a comprehensive understanding of the Jewish Question over the past century and a half, emphasizing the need to address the complexities surrounding this minority group in contemporary society.
Description
The text deliberates the significant influence of the Jewish Lobby in Europe and the United States, highlighting its power across various sectors such as government, finance, media, academia, and entertainment. It presents a historical perspective on the Lobby, referencing thinkers like Nietzsche, Schopenhauer, and Hitler, and critically analyses Holocaust propaganda while examining the Lobby’s current actions. The author, Thomas Dalton, emphasizes the importance of knowledge and encourages readers to engage in a process of renewal to address the challenges posed by this influential group.
Description
The book presents an argument that counters the claim of Soviet anti-Semitism, despite former Israeli Cabinet Member and Education Minister Shulamit Aloni’s public admission in a 2002 interview on ‘Democracy Now’, “Anti-semitic! It’s a trick! We always use it to stifle legitimate criticism of Jews and Zionist Israel.” What’s more, this book also asserts that the USSR was actually pro-Jewish but anti-Zionist, particularly as Zionism became more aggressive. It discusses the historical context of Jewish involvement in Communism, the creation of the Jewish Autonomous Oblast in the USSR, and the eventual rift between Zionist and Communist Jews, particularly following Israel’s increasing nationalism and aggression. The formation of the Anti-Zionist Committee of Soviet Public Opinion in 1983 is highlighted as a response to Zionist claims of anti-Semitism, illustrating the complexities of Jewish identity and political affiliations within the Soviet Union.
_________________________________________________
Dresden: A Real Holocaust | National Vanguard
The Zionists, Sons of the Deceiver, of the dark, are themselves the darkness, the Lie and the Incarnate evil, but they will not prevail and be destroyed.
“A nation can survive its fools and even the ambitious but it cannot survive treason from within. An enemy at the gates is less formidable… The traitor moves amongst those within the gate freely, his sly whispers rustling through all the alleys, heard in the very halls of government itself… He rots the soul of a nation, he works secretly and unknown in the night to undermine the pillars of the city, he infects the body politic so that it can no longer resist.”
Cicero
To all men of good will
of all racial origins and
of all religious faith
Knowledge is a collection of facts.
Wisdom is the use of knowledge.
Without facts there is no knowledge.
Without knowledge there is no wisdom.
Facts prevent what nothing can cure.
Facts are Man’s best defense mechanism.
Without them men fumble, falter and fail.
Without them nations decline and fall.
Wisdom wins wars before they start.
Knowledge aborts national hostilities.
Wisdom obviates racial antipathies.
Knowledge effaces religious animosities.
Emancipation from bigotry prefaces
Intolerance takes all and gives nothing.
Peace rewards reciprocal respect and regard.
To all Men of Good Will, “Pax Vobiscum!”
Benjamin H. Freedman
PODCAST Sources
The podcast episode produced by Q.E.D. – “quod erat demonstrandum” – emphasizes the utilization of peer-reviewed studies and high-quality primary sources. The editorial team meticulously ensures scientific accuracy and adherence to editorial standards. Listeners are encouraged to review the sources cited in the reference section for further validation of the content presented.
Q.E.D. 
Leave a comment